Losing My Perspicacity, May 5, 2025

What do we do with John Fetterman?

Good morning and Happy Monday! Thanks for starting your day with me.

We’re going to start with me just leaving this here.

Great job, America. Really, really good work by everyone involved. I swear to God, living in this country is like being assigned to a group project where 50 percent of the group hasn’t done the reading and has no idea what’s happening. Amazing way to run a country.

Then, yesterday, there was this:

Alcatraz was closed in 1963 because it was too expensive to operate. If it was “too expensive” in 1963, I can’t imagine what it would cost in 2025 dollars — not even taking into consideration what it would cost to bring the whole thing up to code. The “new” cellhouse there was built in 1912, so that gives you some idea of how much “updating” would need to be done. I don’t know what I’m even entertaining this idea. Trump just says whatever comes to mind, moves on, and probably doesn’t give it another thought.

It is worth noting, however, that Alcatraz is part of the National Parks System, which Trump has decimated.

Today: The fallout from the John Fetterman bombshell; 60 Minutes runs a piece on Trump that surely upset Shari Redstone; Trump goes after Big Bird and Terry Gross; and The High Note.

Let’s get into it.

What do we do about John Fetterman?

Full disclosure: I was once a HUGE proponent of John Fetterman and even contributed to his Senate campaign. I wish I knew then what I know now, including what the Black community says about him. In 2022, I was still pretty dug in to sports Twitter, and I apparently missed a lot.

The chaos started on Friday, when NY Mag’s Intelligencer dropped a bombshell exposé on Fetterman’s mental health and ability to do his job. It’s a longform piece, and there’s so much in it that it’s hard to know where to start. I’ll try to hit the highlights.

First, there are suspicions from his former staff that he’s not taking his medication, which he was prescribed both for his depression and because of the stroke he suffered in 2022.

But a year after his release from the hospital, Fetterman’s behavior had so alarmed (former Chief of Staff Adam) Jentleson that he resigned his position. In May 2024, he wrote an urgent letter to David Williamson, the medical director of the traumatic-brain-injury and neuropsychiatry unit at Walter Reed, who had overseen Fetterman’s care at the hospital. “I think John is on a bad trajectory and I’m really worried about him,” the email began. If things didn’t change, Jentleson continued, he was concerned Fetterman “won’t be with us for much longer.”

His 1,600-word email came with the subject line “concerns,” and it contained a list of them, from the seemingly mundane (“He eats fast food multiple times a day”) to the scary (“We do not know if he is taking his meds and his behavior frequently suggests he is not”). “We often see the kind of warning signs we discussed,” Jentleson wrote. “Conspiratorial thinking; megalomania (for example, he claims to be the most knowledgeable source on Israel and Gaza around but his sources are just what he reads in the news — he declines most briefings and never reads memos); high highs and low lows; long, rambling, repetitive and self centered monologues; lying in ways that are painfully, awkwardly obvious to everyone in the room.”

(emphasis added)

YIKES. The article goes on to talk about days when Fetterman shuts down refuses to talk to anyone, which seems bad for a United States Senator.

Members of his team told me this was an early warning sign that something was off with their boss. In early February 2023 — after Fetterman had indeed been sworn in — members of the Senate gathered at the Library of Congress for a caucus retreat. Fetterman, fresh off a hard-fought victory in the cycle’s marquee race, should have been riding high. Only he wasn’t. A staffer recalled getting a text from a person at the retreat asking if their boss was okay. Fetterman was sitting at a table by himself, slowly sipping a Coke and refusing to talk with anybody. Later that day, another staffer heard an alarming report from a journalist: Fetterman had just walked, obliviously, into the road and was nearly struck by a car.

The story details several bizarre events in Fetterman’s tenure in the Senate, including this WTF meeting with then-Senator Sherrod Brown (who should still be in the Senate, dammit).

Brown tried his best to get a conversation going, but according to two people present, Fetterman was virtually “catatonic.” He could barely string two sentences together, talking so quietly that everyone in the room had to strain to hear him. Fetterman then stood up and began walking around the office in tight loops, a move the two staffers described as doing “figure eights.” After Brown left, Fetterman paced from one room inside his office complex to another and back again. At one point, one of his aides said, he walked into the hallway peering over his shoulder, as if he were being followed by shadowy figures.

The staff got in touch with a Senate physician, and everyone agreed: Fetterman needed to get to Walter Reed. He was admitted on February 15.

Next, the article goes into Fetterman’s “full-throated” support for Israel, which included a tweet in opposition to a cease-fire.

But it wasn’t just staffers who were upset. There was also Fetterman’s wife, Gisele, who had become something of a political celebrity in her own right: She is a kindhearted philanthropist (the proprietor of a “free store” in Braddock that gave away goods and clothing), a formerly undocumented immigrant from Brazil, and a vocal progressive. In early November, just weeks after the attack, Gisele arrived at her husband’s Senate office and, according to a staffer present, they got into a heated argument.

“They are bombing refugee camps. How can you support this?” the staffer recalled her saying with tears in her eyes.

“That’s all propaganda,” Fetterman replied.

Later, a still visibly upset Gisele pulled the staffer aside. She asked him if members of Fetterman’s team were pushing him to take these stances for political reasons. The staffer told her that the opposite was true: Many of them were as upset as she was. “If you’re pushing back on this, there’s no hope,” the staffer recalled her saying. “This is horrible news.”

There’s a lot more in the article (Gisele frantically calling Fetterman’s staff, asking why he’s missing their son’s birthday, Fetterman nearly bowling over a crowd of commuters and being utterly oblivious to it), and I included a gift link above so you can check out the whole thing. Nearly every graf has some “WTF"?” revelation.

The piece exploded all over social media Friday morning. By noon, a week-old Penn Live article calling for Fetterman’s resignation, along with a video of Fetterman arguing with an airline pilot about putting on his seatbelt, were also popping up all over the place.

From Penn Live:

Sen. Fetterman has refused to hold town hall meetings in Pennsylvania to hear from his constituents. In fact, the only public event where Fetterman will face the people of the Commonwealth is a joint appearance with Republican Sen. Dave McCormick and his wife Dina Powell, a former Trump administration official, to promote a children’s book written by the Republican power couple.

Enough is enough. Fetterman no longer represents the interests of those who elected him, he seems disinterested in serving in his important position, and his actions in the Senate are actively harming Pennsylvanians. As a Democratic County Party leader, who worked tirelessly to elect Fetterman in 2022, who stood by him through the hardship of his recovery from stroke and depression, his complete abandonment of the core values of our Party has become untenable.

It’s hard to disagree with that. It’s also devastating to think that a stroke could have such a profound effect on someone’s psyche. But then again, maybe he was always this way, and we’ve been fooling ourselves.

What Chan is referring to is an incident where Fetterman chased down a Black jogger and held him at gunpoint until the police arrived in 2013.

John Fetterman said he heard what sounded like gunfire and saw a man running away. So he reacted by getting his kid inside to safety before he called 911.

What Fetterman did next, however, still haunts him nine years later as he campaigns for the Democratic nomination for the Senate in Pennsylvania: He chased the man down with a shotgun and detained him until police arrived.

It turned out that the man was jogging and wearing running clothes. According to a police report, the manwas unarmed and said the sound of gunfire was actually fireworks, although two witnesses thought they heard shots.

Good Lord. We could have had Malcolm Kenyatta.

In a perfect world, Fetterman would resign and allow Pennsylvania Governor Josh Shapiro to appoint someone else. I’d guess that’s unlikely to happen. The Dems, of course, haven’t commented on the NY Mag story, because we can’t do what’s best for the country if it means hurting someone’s feelings. We finally got rid of Joe Manchin and Krysten Sinema, and now we’ve got Fetterman to deal with.

I imagine a lot of strategizing is happening behind the scenes, but given that we can’t even count on Chuck Schumer to get the Democrats in line on voting for Trump’s nominees, I can’t imagine he’ll be able to fix this.

Suck on that, Shari Redstone

Last week, I wrote about how Paramount's majority shareholder, Shari Redstone, had been urging 60 Minutes not to antagonize Trump before her media merger with Skydance Studio (which requires FCC approval) was completed. That kind of corporate interference led 60 Minutes executive producer Bill Owens to resign, claiming he’d lost his journalistic independence at CBS.

Last night, 60 Minutes ran a piece on Trump’s shakedown of law firms that everyone should watch. I hope it tanks her stupid merger.

I can’t imagine the Orange Menace is going to be too happy about that segment, but I’m glad someone is explaining how batshit all of this is in a way that laypeople can understand. Give it a watch when you have some time!

Trump targets PBS, NPR

We all knew this was coming, but it doesn’t make it any easier to take. Last week, Trump signed an executive order (blah) preventing PBS and NPR from receiving taxpayer money.

Both PBS and NPR are, of course, non-profits, with most of their funding coming from viewers/listeners and private donations. Only about 15 percent of PBS’ funding comes from the government, and NPR gets even less — around one percent of its revenue.

The heads of embattled US public broadcasters, National Public Radio (NPR) and the Public Broadcasting Service (PBS), defended themselves against efforts by the Trump administration to cut off taxpayer funding, with both telling a Sunday political talk show they were looking at legal options.

PBS’s chief executive, Paula Kerger, told CBS News’s Face the Nation that Republican-led threats to withdraw federal funding from public broadcasters had been around for decades but are “different this time”.

Kerger said: “They’re coming after us on many different ways … we have never seen a circumstance like this, and obviously we’re going to be pushing back very hard, because what’s at risk are our stations, our public television, our public radio stations across the country.”

PBS calls the EO “blatantly unlawful,” pointing out that the Corporation for Public Broadcasting (CPB), the steward of public broadcasting in the US, is not a federal agency subject to Trump’s whims.

"CPB is not a federal executive agency subject to the President's authority," the corporation wrote in a statement issued Friday morning. "Congress directly authorized and funded CPB to be a private nonprofit corporation wholly independent of the federal government."

***

The CPB noted that the statute Congress passed to create it "expressly forbade 'any department, agency, officer, or employee of the United States to exercise any direction, supervision, or control over educational television or radio broadcasting, or over [CPB] or any of its grantees or contractors."

Congress said that such funds "may be used at the discretion of the recipient" for producing or acquiring programs to put on the air.

While Trump is attempting to deprive PBS of the $535 million it gets from CPB each year, he’s planning a military parade for his birthday that will reportedly cost around $45 million, and his weekly four-day weekends in Mar-a-Lago have already cost taxpayers around $30 million, and it’s only May.

If you don’t already donate to PBS and NPR, now’s a great time to start.

The High Note

Each Day, I do my best to leave you with a smile on your face, a song in your heart, and the will to fight another day.

Today, please enjoy this video of my kick-ass Governor, JB Pritzker, sticking it to Trump on Jimmy Kimmel. I’ve said this before, and I’ll say it again: Most of us voted for Pritzker as the lesser of two evils — Republican Bruce Rauner had been a terrible governor (both Democrats and conservatives hated Rauner) before him, and we mostly closed our eyes and voted for the Democrat. But Pritzker really seems to have found his calling. Sometimes that’s how it happens.

Hey, survive and advance out there today. Don’t let the bastards get you down!

Reply

or to participate.